Long Island has no shortage of ice cream shops—but if you’re tired of the same old chains and want something truly special, this blog is for you. We’ve scooped out some of the most underrated, family-run, or downright delightful ice cream spots across Nassau and Suffolk that locals swear by. Here are the hidden gems to satisfy your sweet tooth:
1. The Snow Factory – Huntington
Why it’s a secret gem: This place is known for its Thai-style rolled ice cream made right in front of you. With unique flavors like lychee and matcha, it’s as much a show as it is dessert.
📍 Visit The Snow Factory
📸 Instagram-worthy rolls and toppings galore!
2. Herrell’s Ice Cream – Huntington
Why it’s special: A little old-school, a lot of flavor. With homemade mix-ins and freshly made whipped cream, Herrell’s is a hidden legend.
📍 Herrell’s Ice Cream
🔥 Must-try: “Smoosh-ins” and their world-famous malted vanilla.
3. Sweet Treats on the Wharf – Port Jefferson
Why locals love it: This waterfront walk-up window serves epic homemade waffle cones and small-batch flavors. A summer-night favorite.
📍 Sweet Treats (Instagram page)
🌊 Grab a cone and stroll the harbor.
4. Kilwins – Babylon Village
What makes it special: Although part of a small chain, the Babylon location feels like a boutique dessert experience with homemade fudge, caramel apples, and rich ice cream.
📍 Kilwins Babylon
💡 Try the toasted coconut or sea-salt caramel fudge.
5. Magic Fountain – Mattituck (North Fork)
Why it’s legendary: Locals know—this spot has over 30 rotating flavors, many made with local ingredients. It’s been serving the North Fork for 50+ years.
📍 Magic Fountain (Instagram)
🍓 Insider tip: Try the “Peconic Swamp Thing” or the seasonal berry blends.
6. Coyle’s Ice Cream – Bay Shore
Why it’s worth the trip: This family-owned retro parlor has massive sundaes, crazy shakes, and a charming diner feel.
📍 Coyle’s Ice Cream
🍨 Great for families and nostalgic vibes.
Final Scoop
Whether you’re team cone, cup, or crazy sundae, these secret ice cream spots on Long Island deliver more than just dessert—they give you a sweet memory. Skip the typical and go local this summer! Let us know about your ice cream store hidden gem.