Top Long Island Neighborhoods for First-Time Homebuyers

Buying your first home is a huge milestone — and choosing the right neighborhood can make all the difference. Whether you’re looking for top schools, walkable communities, or the best bang for your buck, Long Island has incredible options across both Nassau and Suffolk County.

Here are some of the top neighborhoods for first-time homebuyers on Long Island in 2024, based on affordability, lifestyle, and long-term value.

🏡 1. Commack (Suffolk County)

With great schools, parks, and proximity to major highways, Commack is one of Suffolk’s most balanced communities. Home prices are moderate for the area, and you’ll find plenty of starter homes under $600K.

Why first-time buyers love it: Low taxes, quiet blocks, great local shops.

Check out what to eat in Commack →

🏡 2. Levittown (Nassau County)

As one of America’s first planned suburbs, Levittown still offers solid value. Homes are typically smaller, but the location, school system, and community make it a favorite for young families.

Why it works: Central location, affordable property taxes, family-friendly.

🏡 3. Ronkonkoma (Suffolk County)

Thanks to the LIRR and proximity to the Long Island Expressway, Ronkonkoma is great for commuters. The upcoming Midway Crossing development adds even more appeal.

Bonus: Close to the airport and Lake Ronkonkoma!

Nearby: Top school districts in Suffolk →

🏡 4. East Meadow (Nassau County)

Located near Eisenhower Park and Roosevelt Field Mall, East Meadow has something for everyone. Many starter homes here are priced around $500K–$600K.

Why buy here: Community feel + quick NYC access.

🏡 5. Patchogue (Suffolk County)

If you’re looking for a trendy village vibe without the Hamptons price tag, Patchogue is a smart pick. It has restaurants, a growing art scene, and waterfront homes — all at first-time buyer pricing.

Explore great eats in Patchogue →

🔑 First-Time Buyer Tip

Before shopping, get pre-approved and speak with a local agent who knows each area’s hidden gems. Need help? Ask Antonelli here →

📍 Final Thoughts

Long Island can feel overwhelming for first-time buyers — but if you know where to look, you’ll find the perfect mix of affordability, community, and future value. These towns offer a great starting point on your homeownership journey.

Want a personalized list of homes in one of these neighborhoods? Let’s connect →

Top Long Island Neighborhoods for First-Time Homebuyers